I'm currently slogging through Dante's Inferno. I've only played through a single chapter so far, but I can tell you that all the over-the-top demon bashing feels like a pleasant calming walk in the park after the chaos of Darksiders. Darksiders was a cross between Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, God of War, and about 400 Frank Frazetta calendars. It was punishingly long, strangely talky (though it does win some points back for giving Mark Hamill some work) and proudly unoriginal. Dante's Inferno lacks the production design and voice talent, and has super cheesy hand-animated cut-scenes. I guess I can't really recommend either game unless, like me, you've already played through every other 4-to-5 star game available to dork-kind and are just counting time until November when the clouds open and begin to rain sequels down upon us.
Before that was F.E.A.R. 2, which was really neato, and before that was all 4 Red Faction games. You should definitely go pick up Red Faction: Guerilla. I don't throw around the term "glorious orgy of destruction" (G.O.O.D.) too often, but this one qualifies and then some.