Is there a way you can set Purchased to be Sealed by default/auto?
We originally had it that way, but I changed it to the "Select" default because I intend to use the data for the appraisal system, and I want to be able to trust the data. If I just set it to "Sealed" by default, I would never know for sure if the item really WAS sealed, or if the user just wanted to "own" the toy and didn't bother with any of the details (which is okay, too).
If it's really an inconvenience, we could maybe try to think of some other way to force a decision, but also keep the flow quick and painless. One idea would be to replace "Add to my collection" with buttons for "Sealed", "Opened", and "Loose", and you could just click whichever one is appropriate.
Even simpler would be to replace the condition drop-down with a radio button, so it would only require a single click to set (Ed, am I nuts, or has that idea come up before?).